Is The Huffington Post a Blog?

When I go to Technorati’s site and click on its “Top 100” blogs, I don’t actually see web pages I would have ever thought of as blogs.  Keep in mind, I’m relatively new to the blogosphere and headed for that world packing a bag of writing novels and scripts sensibility.  As you’ve heard if you know my stuff, I think about writing as floating on a sea of conversation.  So I’m here beginning a conversation about writing and blogs, and hoping for other voices to join me so that I can get smarter.

The top three blogs as listed on Technorati are “The Huffington Post,” “Mashable,” and “TechCrunch,” all of which I’d call online newspapers.  In fact, the Huffington Post self identifies as a newspaper.  The landing pages of these sites don’t look so different from the front page of a newspaper, and they are full of stories written by perhaps bloggers or maybe journalists.  Got an opinion?


blog, newspaper, website, or a little bit of everything?

Last month–November of 2011–I had a chance to hear Technorati’s annual “State of the Blogosphere” address.  It was given by CEO Shani Higgins and following her presentation, she sat down for a conversation with Mikal Belicove, who writes for Entrepreneur Magazine and co-authored The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Facebook.  Belicove asked Higgins how Technorati defined a blog for the purposes of their State of the Blogosphere report.  After all, since Technorati reported that they surveyed 4,114 bloggers, it stands to reason that they might have had some guidelines to determine who is eligible to take the survey.  Mashable, The Huffington Post, and TechCrunch didn’t take the survey, did they?

click for Arianna Huffington Bio

In response to Belicove’s question, Higgins said she thought it would be a pretty complex task to try and pin down the definition of a blog.  She didn’t offer one herself.  With newspapers failing all the time, I can certainly see where old boundaries between the professional identities of bloggers and journalists are breaking down.  I also see a potential problem between who Technorati surveys and who they list in their “Top 100.” While Arianna Huffington’s work does regularly appear on the front page of the HuffPost, I haven’t exactly thought of her as a blogger.  The site reports that she is, “the president and editor-in-chief of the AOL Huffington Post Media Group.” I don’t think the Huffington Post is anymore a blog than The New York Times.

Listening to Belicove’s questions following the Higgins presentation, I wondered if he had his own definition of a blogger, or if he had a problem with the way Technorati conducted its survey or ranked the most successful blogs.  I tend to think it was the latter–that yes he had a problem with their methods–and I did find that Belicove offers a definition for a blog on his website,

According to, a blog is a frequent chronological publication of personal thoughts and web links.  Short for “weblog,” a blog is often a mixture of what’s happening in a person’s life and what’s happening on the internet, a kind of hybrid diary/guide site, although there are as many types of blogs as there are people.

Wondering if you’ve got opinions regarding the Huffington Post or thoughts connected to newspapers, journalism, or blogs?  When I’m reading around on blogs, I’m often on the lookout for something more densely packed with information, on the lookout for something more than people doing a quick “like” or “comment” with the hopes only that the action will be reciprocated.  I’m starting to find that sort of work online and I hope to share it with you soon.  Love to hear from you on these matters.

Teaching Summer Composition: WordPress Blogs in the Writing/English Classroom

Worth reading: WordPress Blogs IN DEPTH by Bud Smith and Michael McCallister

If anyone has suggestions, I’d love to hear what you think about the following plan:  this summer, for the two sections of composition I’m teaching, I plan to start my own Prof. Torg WordPress blog and have each student writer create a blog of their own.  I’ll have a blog roll (or list of links/same thing?) running down the right edge of my webpage, and all the writers in the class will find each other’s work in that way.  It will be up to each individual student whether or not they want to make their blog public.  I’m leaning towards keeping mine private at first to be safe, but I’d prefer to have it public.

Here’s a list of the main reasons I’m doing this:

  • Each writer has quite a bit of ability in WordPress to customize their own page.
  • Each writer can “tag” or “categorize” their posts.
  • Writers can be referred to other blogs of similar tags or categories.
  • Students will have an authentic audience of each other and if they so choose, an even broader one online.

Page Customization:

There are 99 or so various themes that a person can choose when they set up a WordPress blog.  This seems fun to me, sort of like setting up my office, maybe thinking about the sort of clothes that will define my style, or customizing my character when I play Wii Rock Band.  Last semester, I used NING in conjunction with my course, and there was some capability for each student to make the page look like they wanted it to.  I didn’t even realize this possibility as I started the semester of teaching, but many of my students found their way to this option and did it all on their own.  This seems in tune with what drives people to set up their phones or choose something different for the background on their computers, and exactly the opposite of how many classrooms are set up.  They are set up vanilla; the WordPress blog can be Rocky Road.

I haven’t set down all my philosophical reasons for this, but we all write better, or at least class and the reading we do is more interesting, when we get to know one another.  Some people are great at getting to know people face to face.  Some people can rise up out of a classroom like a whale jumping from the ocean and get noticed.  Others are more quiet, practically invisible, but online they can show their stuff, create a presence on a webpage they don’t create in face-to-face classroom situations.

There’s more to page customization, and I’m just learning about all the possibilities:  various widgets, customized headers, and ways to link to Facebook and Twitter.  When I earned an M.F.A. in creative writing from Georgia College and State University, I used to have this professor, Dr. Dan Bauer, who was always asking us how we knew we were smart or how our students were becoming smarter.  He was very proud that one of his students who was teaching composition answered his question by saying that her students were smart because they realized that writers make choices and they were becoming more aware of all the choices they could make.   I think customizing a WordPress blog has a lot in common with thinking about how one might open a piece of writing.  There are lots of choices and one of the first steps to gaining an audience is to realize that these choices exist.  Otherwise you’re stuck with that typical opening:  In this world today, there are many problems…

Tags and Categories

On WordPress, the blogger has the option to tag their post, which means they are asked to choose keywords that relate to what they’ve just written.  This is good for at least two things.  First, it’s helpful for the writer to think about the key points that they think they are going to write about.  Perhaps the “tag” is a descendant of the topic sentence or the thesis statement.  It’s also sort of psychologically interesting to review one’s tags, to see that when you have the choice to write about anything, what is it that you choose.  There’s also this widget called “Tag Cloud” which will display your key words and make the ones you use the most the largest.  It’s a bit disturbing to me to see that “colonoscopy” still looms large in my tag cloud.

The tags work another way too, perhaps my favorite way.  They give the writers in my class practice at thinking about search words.  Even more than that, I hope that each time my students come to class, the notion of search words is raised in their consciousness.  I watch students all the time try and search a database or even Google, only to give up quickly because they can’t “find any good information.”  What they can’t see, is all the times I’ve tried to search in a database only to have to start over using different keywords.  The less I know about what I’m researching, the more I stink at knowing what words to put in.  That’s when I have to do some reading, so I can learn some important words within the field, so that I can return to the search windows with better words to plug in there.  As my students move from writing and tagging their own posts, to doing research, I hope that this tagging experience will help them move more confidently into using the same kinds of words to find other writers who write about their burgeoning intellectual interests.

Conversation Among Bloggers

There’s something in WordPress called “Tag Surfer.”  For example, I’ve got this novel coming out next January tightly connected to eighties romantic comedies, and I could type in “Cusack” and “Say Anything,” and be presented with a bunch of recent blog posts related to those to tag words.  If I’ve got something to say about Cusack or a John Hughes’s movie, I’m not the only person in the world who has thoughts on the subject.  WordPress can in no time give a literal example of what I find very difficult to teach my students.  If someone is writing about moving from Korea to Queens, NY, they are not the only one writing on this topic, and the databases are even full of scholarly articles related to the subject.  It’s not as easy for me to show this in a database as it is to show it on WordPress.  Also it’s probably not as initially interesting to my students.  On WordPress, the students can quickly experience the conversation that surrounds whatever it is that they’re interested in and then we can all take that experience into the databases when it comes time to do our work in there.  When I ask the writers in my classes who else is writing about their topic, or who the major voices in their field of study are, we can all look back to our WordPress blogging experiences as a foundation for which to understand our scholarly research.  Our use of WordPress can help our understanding of the meaning of a phrase such as “professional conversation.”


Audience is a quick teacher.  It’s that magic weight-loss pill that so many people seem to be looking for.  My students’ writing instantly changes once they realize that their texts are going to–at the least–be read by a writing group in class and not just me.  It’s easy to flip me, the professor, a last-second text and not care if it’s any good or not.  This is not so easy for the students to do to one another.  In general, they don’t want to bore each other.  I am not trying to embarrass anyone; I am trying to put them in conversation with one another.  Students generally think they stink at writing (something they have been taught by teachers I call “-5 sentence fragment” teachers) and so they are at first scared to share, but then also happy to see that nobody else’s writing (especially mine) is perfect.  I don’t even address anyone’s fears about sharing in a group.  I ask students to read their work; I give them the option of somebody else reading their work if they don’t’ want to, and the writing gets read and heard.

Just last night, my wife was compiling her first ever post for her new blog Vegan Mom.  She was deep in concentration, probably irritated that I wouldn’t shut up, and suddenly remarked, “I don’t think I have this in the right order.”  I’d never heard her say anything like this.  My wife certainly does not think of herself as a writer, but she’s written lots of papers for her masters in reading ,and there all of the sudden,  she was making an observation that doesn’t come up very naturally in the classes I teach.  She was making an observation about structure.  What does my reader need to know when?  Not long after her first comment, she said, “This is boring.  I need to put some personality in there.”  Her teacher, if that’s the right word, was that she had an audience, the one she knew waited for her when she hit the WordPress “publish” button.

I first started to think hard about audience when I realized how much I learned from reading the work of my students.  I let them write about whatever they want and so they often to choose to write about where they are from or a topic within their academic major.  Since my students come from all over the world and they’re in the pharmacy program, the physician’s assistant program,  a history major, or business management, they teach me a lot about their interests.  One of the criteria I push students towards, one I have not always stuck to very tightly in my blogging life, is that a reader ought to learn something each time they turn the page.  My students often execute this very well, and so I know a lot more after I finish reading a stack of student writing than I did before I started.  It used to be that I was the only one who benefited from this.  Now my students are part of each others’ education.  Before, they just shared space.  My classroom has become a place where students might make friends.


Perhaps I don’t need to start a new Prof. Torg blog and there is a way that I could manage my summer classes with this one.  Possibly WordPress doesn’t appreciate me having twenty-five or so students putting up blogs, blogs that might die along with the end of the course.   Surely this happens all the time?  I anticipate others having objections related to making someone blog, to abuse the genre in that way.  I guess I’ll find out.  It’s here that I trust conversation, and this time, in a new way within the blogging world and in Facebook and Twitter where these words go first.  I know that I could spend a long time researching all this, but so far, if I can keep from embarrassing myself to much, I like to speak into the world I’m trying to become familiar with.  So here I am now, explaining a plan for my summer teaching, pretty sure that I’m going to hear back from people with various niches of expertise.

Bill Torgerson, Assistant Professor, Institute For Writing Studies, St. John’s University,